Added HexaGrid 2010-07-23
Added CloudStack 2010-19-07
Updated 10:30PM 7-13-2010
Again at 4:30pm 7-14-2010 (added Intalio)
And 6:30 on 7-16-2010 (added Surgient)
It seems like every day there’s a new company touting their infrastructure stack. In recent weeks we’ve seen new offerings from Nimbula and Cloud.com. I’m sure I’m missing some, but I show 20 solutions for building clouds below, and I am sure that more are on their way. The market certainly can’t support so many participants! Not for very long anyway. This is the definition of a “red ocean” situation — lots of noise, and lots of blood in the water.
This is the list of the stacks that I am aware of:
- Eucalyptus Enterprise Editon
- VMware vCloud
- Cloud.com CloudStack
- Enomaly ECP
- CA/3Tera AppLogic
- Abiquo
- Nimbula Director
- Citrix XenCloud
- Univa UniCloud
- Parallels Elastic IT
- RedHat Cloud Foundations
- Surgient Platform
- Morph Labs mCloud
- Joyent Smart OS
- Flexiant Extility
- Platform ISF
- Cloupia Unified Infrastructure Controller
- BMC Cloud Lifecycle Management
- Microsoft Azure Appliance (future)
- Intalio/IaaS
- HexaGrid VxDatacenter
Then there’s the private cloud appliances:
And some open source projects:
I hope you’ll pardon my dubious take, but I can’t possibly understand how most of these will survive. Sure, some will because they are big and others because they are great leaps forward in technology (though I see only a bit of that now). There are three primary markets for stacks: enterprise private clouds, provider public clouds, and public sector clouds. In five years there will probably be at most 5 or 6 companies that matter in the cloud IaaS stack space, and the rest will have gone away or taken different routes to survive and (hopefully) thrive.
If you’re one of the new stack providers – think long and hard about this situation before you make your splash. Sometimes the best strategy is to pick another fight. If you swim in this red ocean, you might end up as shark bait.
Filed under: General,Vendors - Trackback Uri
View Comments.
Trackbacks/Pingbacks
-
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Cloud Bzz. Cloud Bzz said: RT @cloudbzz: The Red Ocean of Cloud Infrastructure Stacks (swim at your peril) http://bit.ly/dfmYZE (let me know if I missed any) [...]
-
[...] on their execution.It seems I am not alone in this skepticism. John Treadway of Cloudbzz recently voiced similar opinion and listed out companies in this space.It seems like every day there’s a new company touting their infrastructure stack. [...]
-
[...] Pro Tweets You read my mind with the Red Ocean of IaaS Stacks post, @cloudbzz (http://www.cloudbzz.com/the-red-ocean-of-cloud-infrastructure-stacks/) randybias – Fri 16 Jul 22:21 All Things [...]
-
[...] launched OpenStack with a reasonable community of boosters. OpenStack aims to disrupt the cloud stack red ocean with a complete open source release of the Rackspace CloudServers compute and CloudFiles object [...]
-
[...] . It seems every few weeks yet another company announces a cloud computing infrastructure platform. I’m not talking about public clouds but the underlying software which can turn a virtualized [...]
-
[...] いささか乱立気味の Cloud 基板 ですが、RackSpace にとっては、技術基盤が Open Source になっても、長年のホスティング事業でこなれた顧客や業務基板、また彼らの特徴であるサポートがあるかぎり安泰と。 [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: "I hope [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market looking more like a red ocean: “I hope [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: "I hope [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] Treadway of Cloud Bzz put together a comprehensive list. He says the market is looking more like a red ocean: “I [...]
-
[...] the Red Ocean of cloud infrastructure stacks Randy refers in his blog has a good list … July 24, 2010 ksankar [...]
John…. Are you not missing the ultimate cloud appliance the VBlock?
John – vBlocks are the infrastructure and virtualization. You still need the cloud control layer to make it work as a cloud. Add Eucalyptus to a vBlock, and you've got the underpinnings of a cloud. Make sense?
You may want to tease apart the list more into discreet buckets. The list is currently mixing virtualization, provisioning, policy management, paas layers and portals. All are ingredients but not really the comparable. This doesn't necessarily affect your assertion, but certainly will affect the deepness of the red. Then again, there should be a third column: product versus vision but that's a different discussion.
John,
You don't consider Microsoft's Windows Azure Platform [Appliance] to be a stack?
–rj
hmmm… okay, sure I'll add them.
Agreed, but too big a project if I start creating matrices etc. Bottom line doesn't change – friggin' crowded market eh?
John, I disagree, you can add VMware’s vCloud or the forthcoming Redwood and accomplish an integrated Cloud Appliance in the same stack as the VCE consortium and is a very effective appliance–i.e., pre-integrated. Much more like IBM Cloudburst or Unisys SPC than cloud like then Just a Bunch Of Disk and Just a Bunch Of Servers. Full Disclosure I work for Acadia/VCE. But I would say similar things about HP’s Matrix and Oracle’s platform for SaaS on Sun storage and servers. Perhaps there is another category in your not so blue ocean—Private Cloud Stacks.
Don't forget Intalio – see http://www.intalio.com/products
Donald – thanks. Yes, if you add Service Director (f/k/a Redwood) to a vBlock it's a private cloud. But vBlock on its own – at least how it's defined now – does not have the self-service provisioning and other pieces to turn it from a great big stack of converged infrastructure to a full-fledged cloud. Technically you can add Unisys SPC to a vBlock because in our model the cloud resource infrastructure pool is independent from the cloud control layer (e.g. we'll work with anybody's gear, at least in principal). Or am I missing something?
Regarding categorization – that gets a bit difficult when you drill into it. Nothing stopping you from using CloudStack or Enomaly for a private cloud, though I might agree that a lot of enterprise process features would be missing (ITIL, ITSM integration, etc.). Not so likely that a private cloud stack like CloudBurst would make a good public cloud engine. Even IBM's own Dev/Test cloud didn't use CloudBurst. Generally, though, it's a bit fuzzy.
Added – thanks
Crowded space tells you a couple things IMHO…
1) when you see fast followers (like in this case) you can rest assured there are end user requirement gaps and this means the technology “isn't good enough”.
and
2) when all you hear is talk about the gaps (reasons it's not good enough) one will soon see “good enough”.
I think you're missing a few still, how about LayerBoom, DAAS (daas.com), Surgient and ElasticHosts ?
Not all aspirants enter the market to end up on top – but to get eaten by the more prosperous. I agree generally with primary market distinctions: enterprise private, provider public, and public sector – but not clear their may be other flavors, or 'mash-ups' yet to evolve.
And what about Verizon or other carriers on here…
please add a new stack named “wakame-vdc” (virtual data center). see also, http://wakame.axsh.jp/vdc.html (Japanese)
John. You are correct. Today vBlocks is neatly packaged infrastructure. Nothing more, nothing less.
Don. OpSource seem to be the guys that have figured out VMWare, Cisco and EMC. They have amazing network capabilities, open APIs and full orchestration on top of a product that is enterprise ready, best of breed, and available today.
John,
Interesting observations…I think it will be interesting to see not only how many “survive”, but how many of those who find themselves in the “top right” of the future Gartner Quadrant in this space, build their offerings on open standards. As many traditional large enterprises (such as the one I work for which shall remain nameless) fight with the concepts of “which cloud”, one of the major draws is the potential elimination of vendor lock-in via the acceptance of open standards. I can’t see how that can be far from the top of the “wanted list” for most IT/Business-savvy folks in positions like mine. I, for one, will be planning carefully for the movement of various workloads in and out of various clouds and, if the pain of doing that is akin to moving workloads from different platforms inside the “firewall” today, then I will know I’ve bet on the wrong horse…..
Best,
Christian
Two more for your list! Skydera, and Attribo. See
http://cloudcomputing.info/en/news/2010/08/skyd...
and
http://cloudcomputing.info/en/news/2010/08/attr...
This is getting remarkably silly, isn't it?
You should look into IBM's Tivoli and Systems Director VMControl solutions as well. They aren't packaged as a private cloud solution just yet, but they allow for the management of VMs as well as workload automation and provisioning. I think they are in the same position as HP's BTO and Cloud Assure – products whose roots were in datacenter and IT management but are being either rebranded or repurposed for the cloud.
Thanks. There are many IT automation tools that could be used in cloud stacks, but unless they are packaged as such I won't include them here. Best.
Yes, it is.
Skydera and Attribo are more like cloud management tool plays – perhaps a bit like an enStratus, RightScale, or newScale. They manage AWS and other clouds, but don't provide the stack to build a cloud.
Let me know if you find more.
Thanks
one more for your list: Convirture offers private cloud management with a focus on open source virtualization technologies (KVM, Xen)
http://www.convirture.com/index.php
http://www.convirture.com/solutions_cloudcomput...
You need to add deltacloud.org to this list.
You need to add deltacloud.org to this list.